In a legal twist from the Sunshine State, a Floridian woman named Cynthia Kelly is taking on The Hershey Company with a whopping $5 million lawsuit. The allegedly deceptive packaging of Reese’s seasonal-shaped chocolates. The Tampa resident claims that the sweet giant has pulled a confectionery trick on customers by showcasing images on the packaging that don’t quite match the actual shape of the chocolates.
According to the lawsuit, filed in Florida’s Middle District Court, the pumpkin-shaped chocolates failed to live up to their packaging promises. Kelly asserts that the depicted carved eyes and mouth on the packaging were nowhere to be found on the actual treats. Not stopping at pumpkins, she argues that the football-shaped chocolates ended up looking more like eggs, leaving a trail of dissatisfied customers in their wake.
The crux of Kelly’s legal argument revolves around the notion that Hershey’s labels for these products are, in her view, “materially misleading”. She claims that a significant number of consumers, herself included, felt “tricked and misled” by the alluring pictures on the packaging, sparking the need for a legal showdown.
Kelly’s personal experience further fuels the legal fire. She avows that she shelled out $4.49 for a bag of pumpkin-shaped candies at Aldi, expecting to sink her teeth into the deliciousness promised by the carved pumpkin face featured on the packaging. To her dismay, the snack-sized Reese’s did not live up to the artistic carvings hype, prompting her to take legal action.
The lawsuit doesn’t confine itself to pumpkins alone. It extends its grip to other seasonal shapes like ghosts, bats, footballs, snowmen, and bells, with photographic evidence presented in the legal dossier. Kelly contends that Reese’s packaging used to be reliable and accurate, lamenting that the products from “two to three years ago” matched the images on the package and lacked the current trend of sporting faces.
To add a dash of social media spice to the legal mix, Kelly cites several YouTube videos where creators accused Reese’s of “lying” and “failing” to deliver on their packaging promises. The lawsuit, taking on a class-action stance, aims to represent “all consumers within the State of Florida who purchased one of the products,” turning a candy dispute into a legal battle of statewide proportions.
Comments